By Honorable John Paul Stevens, Justice, U.S. Supreme Court
On December 6, 1941, having completed the Navy’s restricted correspondence course in cryptography, I went to the Great Lakes, Naval Station, applied for a commission and passed the physical. I’m sure you know how the enemy responded the following day. A few weeks later my orders arrived and I spend most of 1942, working in OP-20-GT in the old Munitions Building on Constitution Avenue. (I never made it to the roof). I served under then LCDR Jeff Dennis, made a few “idents” (call sign identification) and a garble table for the enemy’s 3-kana calls. I spent ’43, ’44 and over half of ’45 at Pearl, and was returned to Washington shortly before VJ day. When I arrived at Pearl, the unit-then known as FRUPAC was still in the basement of Com-14, but some months later we became part of JICPOA up at Makalapa.
My principal memories are of the exceptionally fine bunch of men – both officers and enlisted- who worked in the unit. As you know, many of them were musicians, having been numbers of the band on a battle wagon (I think it was the California). For most of my tour I served as a watch officer on the traffic analysis desk; every third or fourth day (our watch schedules changed from time to time) I prepared the report on the previous 24 hours of intercepted traffic that was sent to Commander Layton at Cinpac the first thing in the morning. I learned what really lousy coffee tastes like, and eventually come to like it. I happened to be on duty when the message came in advising that our pilots had bagged a peacock and two sparrows; I had mixed feelings at the time because, on the on hand it was an important and successful operation, but on the other hand, it was a deliberate elimination of a specific individual rather than a nameless enemy.
Our routines were more informal than many in the navy. For example, I remember Stanley Moe, a yeoman, who was our expert in reading enemy weather traffic. He would start analyzing the new intercept promptly after 00:00 minus nine time and would often have everything figured out in a couple of hours. He, Kimmy Lee, and I worked together around the clock for three or four days to break a new daily-changing call sign encyperment system, with the familiar weather intercepts providing the raw material for the reconstruction of what turned out to be a very simple strip cipher. I remember the incident with particular pleasure because several days after we had the whole thing figured out, we were still getting messages from Washington advising us that they had recovered a few values.
That incident was small potatoes compared to the magnificent accomplishments of the geniuses who were recovering JN-25 additives and translating 5-digit values into plain language. Despite occasional problems with garbles, traffic analysis also made significant contribution to our understanding of what the enemy was up to. Altogether, what I saw at Pearl convinced me that the value of the work done there-both before the War started and while it was being fought- was seriously underestimated by the folks in Washington. The unit never received as much credit as it should have. I am convinced that Admiral Kimmel was unfairly held responsible for our failure to anticipate the surprise attack on Pearl and sincerely hope that he will one day be vindicated.
I would like to mention by name all the fine people who I worked with but time (in two senses – I’m under some pressure right now, and the passage of a half-century has blurred some wonderful memories) prevents me from doing so.
Editor’s note by George P. McGinnes: John Paul Stevens’ reference to the bagging of the peacock and two sparrows refers to the U.S. Army Air Corps shoot-down of Japanese Admiral Yamamoto and his entourage in two separate aircraft. This was a direct result of the U.S. Navy reading a message about Yamamoto’s intended tour of the Shortland Islands. Justice Stevens spoke at the dedication of the On-The Roof Gang memorial at 3801 Nebraska Ave. NW on June 17, 1983.
Editor’s notes by Mario Vulcano:
John Paul Stevens (born April 20, 1920) is a retired associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States who served from December 19, 1975 until his retirement on June 29, 2010. At the time of his retirement, he was the oldest Justice then serving, the second-oldest serving Justice in the history of the Court, and the third longest-serving US Supreme Court Justice in history. He was nominated by President Gerald Ford to replace the Court’s longest-serving justice, William O. Douglas.
OP-20-GT is where Traffic Analysis was performed within the OP-20 organization
Musicians from the USS California – Many of Rochefort’s men were bandsmen from the battleship CALIFORNIA, damaged at Pearl Harbor. Rochefort thought their musical skills might make them adept codebreakers in much the same way that Marine bandsmen used to serve as fire control technicians on ship — the ability to quickly read and play music made them excellent mathematical problem solvers.
The roof refers to a unique training classroom on the roof of the Main Navy Building. Classes were held between 1928 and 1941. Students were training in Japanese Kata kana and basic cryptanalysis.
FRUPAC – (Fleet Radio Unit Pacific) also known as Station HPYO was the United States Navy signals monitoring and cryptographic intelligence unit in Hawaii during World War II.
20 July 2023 at 06:44
I enjoyed reading this. Thank you, Mario.
Jim King
CTOC Ret.
LikeLiked by 1 person
21 July 2023 at 23:14
Ditto to Jim King’s comment directly above.
JICPOA to those who may not know stands for Joint Intelligence Center, Pacific Ocean Area. JICPOA was the successor organization to FRUPAC. FRUPAC resulted when the “Combat” [a.k.a. Communications] Intelligence Unit of the 14th Naval District was placed under Admiral (later Fleet Admiral) C.W. Nimitz rather than Commandant, Fourteenth Naval District.
I would love to ask Justice Stevens to explain his remark about Admiral Kimmel’s publicly presumed failure to “anticipate the surprise attack” of 7 Dec. 1941. It’s my belief that Admirals Kimmel and Bloch and other flag and general officers on Oahu in early December 1941 were merely doing what they had been ordered to do, i.e., “United States desires Japan to commit the first overt act.” (See G.C. Marshall dispatch to LG W.C. Short of 27 Nov. 1941, and OPNAV 290110, of Nov. 1941.)
Should the Honorable Justice Stevens care to respond, I can be reached via email at: amckane4@reagan.com, or via my post office address: P.O. Box 166, Maunaloa, Hawaii 96770. Our phone number(s) are available from Mario.
For the record, I have the utmost respect for the work done by CIU, Pearl Harbor under then Commander J.J. Rochefort in the period leading up to 7 Dec. 1941 and all throughout World War II (under its various names and various officers in charge). Intelligence isn’t always used the way the average citizen assumes it is used. American leadership on the eve of Pearl Harbor were primarily concerned with the unification of the American people. For the record, it is my belief our leadership—from the President on down through the various military leaders—could not have been better.
Thank you Mr. Justice Stevens for your long and devoted service to the United States of America, to the American people, and to our beloved Navy.
Great work with all your HYPO postings, Mario!
Andy McKane
1314, Hawaiian time, Friday, 21 July 2023,
On vacation at Marriott’s Waikoloa Beach facility, Hawaii Island
LikeLike