First Overt Act (25)
Captain Edwin T. Layton probably gave a better summation of why we had Pearl Harbor than any historian has provided in the years since the end of World War II. As Layton explained to the Army Pearl Harbor Board in 1944: “Our people were not charged up to go fight until after Pearl Harbor was hit.” (26)
One might ask, Why not allow the Pacific Fleet to fight a sea engagement off Oahu at the initiation of hostilities? According to Layton: “I think the American forces here would have taken the licking of their life….because the American people were not psychologically prepared for war.” (27)
American war plans developed and prepared prior to December 1941 placed the Pacific Fleet in “a waiting attitude” and established the policy of “the first overt act” being committed against the United States rather than by the United States. (28)
Prior to assuming command of the Pacific Fleet on 1 February 1941, Admiral Kimmel told Commander John L. McCrea: “Tell Admiral Stark that I will do my utmost in this job. I will be guided in what I do by what I think is best for the country.”*
In January 1941 while McCrea was discussing the new war plan with Admiral Thomas C. Hart in Manila, Hart told McCrea: “I feel certain that [Japan] won’t jump us unless they feel certain that in so doing they can attain a tremendous initial advantage….I do not feel that the destruction of the entire Asiatic Fleet would be regarded by them as such an `initial advantage.’”**
A key element of the ORANGE war plan that was omitted from the Rainbow 3 and the later Rainbow 5 war plans reads as follows:
“The Army and Naval Forces stationed in the HAWAIIAN ISLANDS
will be prepared at all times to defend OAHU against all forms of
surprise attack, including the following: (a) Gun, torpedo, and
bombing raids, mining operations, and a possible landing of minor
forces. (b) Attempts to enter PEARL HARBOR or HONOLULU
HARBOR, or to close those harbors by blockships. (c) Sabotage or
The omission of Change No. 6 of the Orange War Plan from Rainbow 3 and Rainbow 5 war plans, effectively led to what occurred on Oahu on 7 December 1941. Put another way, it was no longer desired that the Army and Navy would “be prepared at all times to defend Oahu against all forms of surprise attack.” (29)
The War Department’s war warning, sent as dispatch #472 to Lieutenant General Walter C. Short on 27 November 1941, confirms the above: “If hostilities cannot, repeat cannot, be avoided the United States desires that Japan commit the first overt act.”30 On 28 November this same message, containing the exact same phrase, was sent by Admiral Stark to Admiral Kimmel and other naval officers. (31)
In his Reminiscences, General of the Army Douglas MacArthur described the effect of the war warning dispatch in this way: “My orders from Washington were not to initiate hostilities against the Japanese under any circumstances. The first overt move in the Philippine area must come from the enemy.” (32) Admiral Kimmel and General Short could have used the exact same words to describe their situation by substituting the words “Hawaiian area” for “Philippine area.”
The first two sentences in Section II – Assumptions of the Hawaiian Defense plans read as follows: “1. There will be a period of strained relations preceding the outbreak of war with ORANGE….2. Active hostilities against the UNITED STATES by ORANGE will be precipitated without a formal declaration of war.”****
Pacific Fleet Confidential Letter 2CL-41 of 14 October 1941 includes the following statement: “(b) That a declaration of war may be preceded by: (1) a surprise attack on ships in Pearl Harbor. (2) a surprise submarine attack on ships in operating area. (33) (3) a combination of these two.”*****
Operation Plan No. 1-41 of December 1941 circulated by the Commandant, Fourteenth Naval District, Rear Admiral Claude C. Bloch, advised the Harbor Control post at Pearl Harbor: “…be prepared to `alert’ Army and Navy forces against aircraft or other surprise attack, and assist in coordinating their defense measures.”(34)
On 2 December 1941, Rear Admiral Bloch circulated Local Base Defense Force Order No. 1. Enclosed with this letter was a “special military map” of Oahu, and, “1. The unified grid system as used by the U.S. Army will be adopted for use of the Naval Local Base Defense Force.”(35)
On 4 December 1941, Admiral Kimmel circulated Pacific Fleet Confidential Letter No. 16CL-41. The subject of 16CL-41 was, U.S. Army Position Grid—Hawaiian Area. All ships presently in port at Pearl Harbor received 16CL-41 and the “unified grid system” documents that were associated with it. (36)
One indication that Magic was available on Oahu is found in a memorandum by Lieutenant Colonel George W. Bicknell, titled Seizure and Detention Plan (Japanese). This document is dated 21 November 1941. The assistant G-2 of the Hawaiian Department’s memo begins; “1. It is quite possible that war may develop with Japan with or without a formal declaration, in the near future.”
Under item 5 is stated: “Plan II considers the situation which would exist in a general Pacific war with the United States Fleet (or a considerable portion thereof) in Hawaiian waters but with threats of surprise raids (by air or surface craft) against the Hawaiian Islands.” (37)
An indication that the “winds execute” message had been intercepted is contained in a telegram from Manila to the Theo. H. Davies Company in Honolulu. This telegram reads, in part: “C. Our considered opinion concludes that Japan invisages [sic] early hostilities with Britain and U.S. Japan does not, repeat not intend to attack Russia. You may inform Chiefs of American Military and Naval Intelligence [in] Honolulu.” Copies of this telegram were given to “Col. Bicknell, Mr. [Robert L.] Shivers [FBI Agent in Charge, Honolulu], and Capt. Mayfield.” (38)
The Japanese Navy’s execute for war was sent by Admiral Yamamoto, Commander-in-Chief, Combined Fleet to all units of the Combined Fleet. This message, “Climb Niitakayama 1208, repeat 1208!,” was intercepted by Station HYPO at 2100, 2 December 1941 (GMT). (39)
For all intents and purposes United States diplomatic relations with Japan were terminated on 26 November 1941. (40) Secretary of State Cordell Hull and others in the Roosevelt Administration knew the Japanese Government would not accept the terms of the U.S. 10-Point Note. (41)
The Navy’s “most accomplished and experienced intelligence expert,” Captain Ellis M. Zacharias, had dinner with Lorrin Thurston and his wife in their home on 27 November 1941. In his book, Captain Zacharias wrote that in the Thurston’s living room after dinner, “for three hours, we discussed the situation. I revealed to them in detail what I had told Admiral Kimmel and [Curtis B.] Munson….as I concluded the careful analysis of past events and those soon to come, he [Thurston] suddenly exclaimed, `Here I am, a reserve officer in G-two, and I haven’t even been advised what to send out over my radio in case of an attack!’” (42)
On Sunday, 30 November 1941, the front page headlines of Lorrin Thurston’s Honolulu Advertiser warned: “Japanese May Strike Over Weekend!” and “Kurusu Bluntly Warned Nation Ready for Battle.”(43)
During his testimony to the Roberts Commission on Thursday, 8 January 1942, Captain Zacharias stated: “I consider that on the 1st of December, 1941, we had an excellent and efficient intelligence organization working in Hawaii.” (44)
Just as surely as the Japanese Navy used strategy in planning their opening moves of the Pacific War, high level officials of the United States provoked Japan into committing the first overt act. American strategy allowed the sacrifice of obsolete ships and of X-number of lives on Oahu on Sunday, 7 December 1941. (45)
The strategic lesson of Pearl Harbor is that when we deceive ourselves as to how past events happened, we condemn ourselves to repeat similar events in the future. (46)
* A twenty-three page “secret” Memorandum for Admiral Stark of 5 February 1941 is published as Appendix B in the Reminiscences of Vice Admiral John L. McCrea, U.S. Navy (Ret.), U.S. Naval Institute, Annapolis, Maryland, 1990, quoted from p. 22. McCrea’s memo was not furnished to any investigation into Pearl Harbor.
** Ibid, McCrea memo, p. 14.
*** See Changes in Joint Basic War Plan – ORANGE, JB No. 325 (Serial 594), signed by the then Chief of Naval Operations, Admiral William H. Standley, and approved by Secretary of the Navy Claude A. Swanson, 9 December 1936. This was inserted as Change No. 6 to the Orange war plan on 26 March 1937. Admiral Standley was one of the five members of the Roberts Commission that investigated Pearl Harbor.
**** JCC Exhibit 44, Copies of Defense Plans (Hawaiian Department & Fourteenth Naval District), as revised 11 April 1941, PHA15, p. 1423. (The full text of Exhibit 44 is found in PHA15, pp. 1423-1471.)
*****Pacific Fleet Confidential Letter No. 2CL-41 (Revised), 14 October 1941. Quoted from JCC Exhibit 44, PHA15, p. 1453. This document and its earlier version were used as exhibits of some of the earlier investigations into Pearl Harbor. 2CL-41 of 14 Oct. 1941 is also published as an appendix in Admiral Kimmel’s Story, by Rear Admiral H.E. Kimmel, Henry Regnery Company, Chicago, 1955, see pp. 189-201, quoted from p. 190.
By Mr. Andy McKane
10 December 2018 at 12:58
Everyone knew that a war with Japan (or even Germany) was coming. You could predict that if could happen in Late November or in December, but I yet to read anything that pointed to 8 Am Dec 7th at Pearl Harbor, except the delivery time and date of the 14 part “ultimatum” message, which was supposed to be delivered by the Japanese embassy in DC, Sunday at 8 AM, Hawaii time.
rsl – CTRCS Ret
LikeLiked by 1 person
10 December 2018 at 15:45
I thought the message from Yamamoto on 2 December saying “climb Niitakayama 1208 repeat 1208” was a clear reference that something big was going to happen on 7 December. The message was sent to “all units of the combined fleet and 1208 (Dec 8th) Tokyo time would be 7 December Honolulu time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
30 May 2019 at 06:21
on 26 November, 1941, @ 9 AM, FDR was wheelchaired out of his WH bedroom and down to the basement radio-telephone office to receive a (scrambled) RT call from Brit PM Churchill. In the course of this conversation, WC gave FDR the target (Pearl Harbor), the composition of the Japanese attacking force (6 carriers), and the date (8 Dec., Tokyo time). The two leaders then discussed how to deal with the situation so as to best promote America’s entry into the World War. How do we know this? The Germans had an RT intercept/de-scramble station on the Dutch coast which had begun picking off Roosevelt-Churchill conversations beginning in September. Where did WC get his information? Brit Far East Intel had cracked substantial portions of the IJN code. Stay tuned, more to come.
LikeLiked by 1 person
3 June 2019 at 19:02
Thank you for the above information. I’ve spent the past several days considering how to handle what Haxo Angmark has written. I will contact Mr. Angmark today. Many thanks to all concerned, Andy McKane, 0901 (Hawaiian Time), Monday, 3 June 2019.
17 April 2022 at 16:37
LTC Clifford M. Andrew as a younger intelligence officer was put in charge of the Technical Branch of the Army Intelligence Office in the basement of the Iolani Palace in Honolulu. Working under the direct orders of President Roosevelt, he was ordered not to give in vital intelligence information relating to the whereabouts of the Japanese fleet to the commanders in the field. He had been put in charge of all radio communications and more than that. You don’t have enough room for the story. He died of a bullet in the head May 15, 1966 in Tigard Oregon. All of that is another story. I inherited three boxes of records on Pearl Harbor from his estate. In there were secret records of all the communication equipment and decoding equipment. For me to stay alive my father burnt most of those records. I am sure I saw the red machine and the purple machine. I certainly saw the antennas of the intercept station and the top secret transmitter and receiver station in the pineabple grove. Andrew and two other intelligence officers burnt the message he had received from the Whitehouse warning ofthe attack along with about 40-50 four drawer file cabinets to keep the investigating committees from learning the truth of what actually happened at Pearl Harbor. Andrew’s death was taken over from the Tigard Oregon Police Department, taken over by the FBI, and written down as a apparent suicide. I doubth that considering the location of the skull and blood matter in his home. Plus, on Thursday prior to his death, I probably saw the man that killed him. I believe I kept that quiet for many years. In my mind, I can still see pictures of the decoding equipment. I am 75 years old now. I was LTC Clifford M. Andrew’s and his wife Rita’s Houseboy.
LikeLiked by 1 person
18 April 2022 at 23:18
Dear Mr. Stolley: I received notice of what you wrote yesterday immediately prior to accompanying my wife to church for the Easter Sunday church service.
What you wrote about the late Lieutenant Colonel Clifford M. Andrew was and is of considerable interest to me. Indeed, what you wrote may well be the single most important information I’ve received in the last 38 years of Pearl Harbor research.
We are almost the same age. I turned 74 on 26 March. I began reading about Pearl Harbor and the Pacific War while living with my family on Oahu in the mid-1950’s, and again from 1959-1961. My father at that time was in the Navy. We lived less than a mile from the main gate onto the Pearl Harbor Naval Base.
I have many questions I’d like to discuss with you. I can do so either in writing, on the telephone, or, if you prefer, we can meet in person at your convenience, anywhere you wish to meet.
My contact information: firstname.lastname@example.org. This is THE best way to reach me. I work at home. I check emails two or three times daily. My post office box address is: PO Box 166, Maunaloa, Hawaii 96770. (My physical street address, which does not work as a mailing address, is: 98 Pu’unana Street, Maunaloa, Molokai, Hawaii 96770.)
My cellphone number is: 808-658-5137. (Normally I do not have my cellphone in the office of my home. Due to the nature of your information, however, I’ll keep my cellphone on my desk until hearing back from you.) A second and generally far more reliable contact number is: 801-837-0098. This is my wife, Debbie’s, cellphone number. Although she lives here on Molokai with me, she still has our old Utah (801) area code. Deb carries her cellphone with her or has it next to her 7/24/365.
I’ve long believed the Army—as well as the Navy—operated a communications intelligence facility on Oahu prior to the outbreak of the Japanese-American war. I’ve read all 39-volumes of the Pearl Harbor Attack Hearings (PHA). I’ve also indexed the vast majority of the material from these eight U.S. Government investigations. In spending over 38 years of my life seriously researching Pearl Harbor, I’ve long since come to the conclusion that considerable intelligence was on hand with senior military commanders on Oahu just as it was in the War and Navy Departments.
I have two Facebook pages. The one you will be most interested in is PEARL HARBOR MCKANE. A second, more personal Facebook page is: ANDREW “ANDY” MCKANE.
Thank you very, very much, Mr. Stolley. I look forward to hearing from you!
Most sincerely, Andy McKane, 1317 (Hawaiian time), Monday, 18 April 2022.